Our Favorite Pizza Places in Loveland & NoCo.

There's a lot of competition for best pizza in Loveland & NoCo, but here are some of our favorites

By Melissa Shrader Editor Publisher Loveland Macaroni Kid August 25, 2021

Oh, pizza. How we love you. Let us count the ways: Pizza makes dinner a breeze on the nights when cooking is just not gonna happen. No one in the family ever complains about pizza night, and pizza is DELICIOUS.

Pass me another slice, please.

FYI: Drop in on September 5th and celebrate Cheese Pizza  Day. 

We are lucky we have a lot of locally-owned great pizza shops in Loveland & NoCo to satisfy any and all pizza cravings. Here are our 5 favorite locally-owned spots for pizza in Loveland & NoCo:

Krazy Karls

2620 S. Timberline Rd.
Fort Collins, CO 80525

(970) 223-8600


1124 W. Elizabeth St
Fort Collins, CO 80521

(970) 224-2000


225 E. 29th St.
Loveland, CO 80538


What we love: Krazy Karls has so many unique items that other pizza places don't have. Bacon Gouda bites, Giant Reuben Grinders, 6 different salads while others offer 2, Alfredo pizza, Cousin Vinny Pizza, North or South of the Border pizza, and the Mac'd up put a different spin on pizza as you know it. They do have a killer pepperoni pizza too. 

MOD Pizza

1013 Centre Ave
Fort Collins, CO 80526
(970) 484-3497

What we love: All their pizzas are artisan style. The salads are delicious. Everything tastes like it was made especially for you. 

Pizza Palace Ice Cream & Subs

3810 Cleveland Avenue
Wellington, Colorado 80549


What we love: Not many places have Manacoti but Pizza Palace does! Shakes and malts with or after a pizza hit the spot. Their subs, strombolis, and pizzas are delicious! 

Windsor Brick Oven

1215 Main Street Unit I
Windsor, CO 80550
(970) 686-9967

What we love: By the slice, by the pie, you will love the variety of flavors. Strombolis, subs, calzones, hot wings, salads, dessert pizzas, and gluten-free options. 

Pelican Jo's Pizzaria 

903 Broad Street
Milliken, CO 80543
(970) 660-8893


263 Eastman Park Drive
Windsor, CO 80550:
(970) 686-7297

What we love: Unique flavors like Artichoke chicken, Mango Habenero, John Wayne, The Kitchen sink pizza's all offer something for everyone. They have a great kid's menu. They have wonderful pasta, wings, salads, and onion rings are some of the delicious choices they offer.  They have a delicious gluten-free cauliflower crust too!